Try the political quiz
+

Filter by author

Narrow down the conversation to these participants:

194 Replies

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

No

 @B2G8J4B from Pennsylvania  agreed…6mos6MO

In 2022, S&P 500 companies spent $922.7 billion on stock buybacks, compared to $565 billion on dividends. This demonstrates their role as a major way corporations return value to shareholders. Around 58% of U.S. adults own stocks, either directly or through retirement accounts like 401(k)s. Stock buybacks boost the value of these investments, indirectly benefiting millions of Americans.

 @9FVCWNT from California  disagreed…2yrs2Y

Under regular market conditions, the portion of profits that a company uses to buy back shares has a positive effect on the share price. For instance, a listed company has 1,000 shares of which a shareholder owns 100 a 10% stake.

 @9FW9Y8VProgressive from Georgia  disagreed…2yrs2Y

It allows for a loophole for the people of the highest brackets to not pay taxes, they are scamming the nation and something must be done.

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

Yes, but I would prefer if they were banned

 @B2G8J4B from Pennsylvania  disagreed…6mos6MO

Stock buybacks are an essential tool for capital allocation in a free market economy, and banning them could harm companies, shareholders, and the
whole economy.

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

No, the biggest beneficiary of stock buybacks are pension funds and mutual funds

 @9LYBLHD from Texas  disagreed…1yr1Y

If corporations are allowed stock buybacks they should be taxed at the degree of their buyback. Furthermore, the companies are making their companies more valuable than what they are.

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

No, there is no evidence that firms that engage in buybacks reduce their investments

 @99MT3SV from Kansas  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9P7MH8N from Illinois  answered…1yr1Y

Stock trading is evil and should be abolished. Businesses should be owned entirely by their workers.

  @YauntiCommunist from New York  answered…2yrs2Y

 @B3GGFNK from Illinois  answered…4mos4MO

If the stock issuance is defined to be the cost basis of the stock, a buyback is probably a capital loss and should not be taxed.

 @8TLN5QMCommunist  from PR  answered…4mos4MO

Yes, and allow for everyday people to buy and own as many stocks as we can afford. More people owning capital is better than it being in the hands of just a few or corporations.

 @9TQ8JH6 from Pennsylvania  answered…10mos10MO

There should be at least some incentive for corporations to make additional investments rather than buy back stock.

 @84ZWD6LLibertarian  from Pennsylvania  answered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but in the form of a reformed corporate tax code where there is no income tax and only a tax on distributions, including stock buybacks

 @9XMGBFBfrom Maine  answered…8mos8MO

You need to take into account the amount of capital. No taxes for small investors, and a progressive tax rate for large investors.

 @9TFPG5N from Iowa  answered…10mos10MO

Yes and No, I believe that we shouldn't be taxing stock buybacks, UNLESS, there is something severely wrong with that specific buyback. Now while I also believe that most brokers tend to be crooks, they're just doing they're job, doing what they're good at, and surviving off of it. It's just business

 @9QS6HSL from Ohio  answered…12mos12MO

Yes, and all trades, shares, and dividends should be heavily taxed to fund a single Payor health system.

 @9KC7KKX from California  answered…1yr1Y

No, conmpanies need their shares back for their benefit. Government should not tax from shares, but firms and households' own money to make sure each of them contribute the government's protection in return.

 @9F75VT4 from Illinois  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9F6FCKH from California  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DYZ9T3 from Kansas  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DTKLB3Democrat from Illinois  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DKXV4X from New Jersey  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DCZMS3 from Texas  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DBLV5J from New Jersey  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9DBCJWSLibertarian from California  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9LJJY8L from New York  answered…1yr1Y

Yes. Stock buybacks can inflate a company’s stock price even if its financial performance is low. This can persuade naive investors into buying shares for a company that is conflating its current financial reputation in a positive light with regard to the buybacks

 @9JPPDJWDemocrat from Illinois  answered…1yr1Y

Government should determine the best way to appropriately tax all individuals and if this is even the best way to add revenue to the country's balance sheet. It should be taken into consideration with all other methods of taxation.

  @charlie3sticks from Guam  answered…1yr1Y

No - they should end the tyranny of the stock exchange all together so companies can run their business as they intended. They should provide open funding with proportional shares being distributed through a national pension program that is paid out via dividend.

 @9FPHT6Mfrom Maine  answered…2yrs2Y

No, except if the stocks are being bought back from the government following a bail-out

 @mwlkybun from Louisiana  answered…2yrs2Y

I feel like if the company wants to buy back their stocks then it’s up to try to get them back at whatever monetary cost.

 @6VWJ8PP  from Wisconsin  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9BXLFGR from Pennsylvania  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9HQN3KL  from Texas  answered…2yrs2Y

its not a simple yes or no the question of whether the government should tax stock buybacks involves weighing different factors and considering various viewpoints.

 @9D5CHFN from Maryland  answered…2yrs2Y

 @Baileyhargrave from Kansas  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9CH39KH from Pennsylvania  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9BDTBPD from California  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9BDPXFP from North Carolina  answered…2yrs2Y

 @7YY64YV from Nevada  answered…2yrs2Y

Regardless, the government should pass a minimal tax all financial transactions.

 @99T5NLDDemocrat from Florida  answered…2yrs2Y

 @99MMB9F from California  answered…2yrs2Y

 @99GRKC8Progressive from Texas  answered…2yrs2Y

No, but capital gains taxed at the same or greater rates as income taxes.

 @99GK7TT from Missouri  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9BPNRP9Republican from Utah  answered…2yrs2Y

i do not have the proper knowledge to accuretly make am informed choice.

 @9B8SVLK from Georgia  answered…2yrs2Y

 @9B428S5 from Washington  answered…2yrs2Y

 @99ZW2HSCommunist from Kentucky  answered…2yrs2Y

No, but abolish the stock market and nationalize all corporations, transition them to well-regulated, unionized worker cooperatives, and ban the private sector

 @Oatesi from Ohio  answered…2yrs2Y

I do not consider myself to understand the topic enough to be confident in holding an opinion.

 @99G7RPQ from Arkansas  answered…2yrs2Y

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...