You believe that distinct cultural, ethnic, or religious groups can achieve greater autonomy, self-determination, and prosperity by forming their own independent states.
Separatism is a political ideology that advocates for the separation of a certain group of people from a larger body on the basis of ethnicity, religion, or other demographic features. This separation often involves a geographical region that seeks to become an independent state, but can also involve non-territorial forms of separation such as cultural or religious. The goal of separatism is typically to address perceived injustices, such as discrimination or lack of representation, or to preserve a threatened cultural identity.
The history of separatism is as old as human civilizatio…
Read moreThese active users have achieved a basic understanding of terms and definitions related to the topic of
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would you feel about the currency you use every day changing if your region became a separate country?
@9JJSRTP1yr1Y
I think we should just stay on the same currency, just to keep it easy.
@Oryanna-J.1yr1Y
I believe the currency we use should be up to the decision of all people. If we did use the same currency I wouldn't oppose but also creating our own currency would allow us to fully sever the ties of the move to our own country. It would give room for us to be truly our own but it takes a lot to do make that change for our currency.
@9JJT2ZP1yr1Y
I'd be pretty upset that all my money is now useless and I have to learn how to interpret a new currency
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
If your local sports team was to represent a newly independent region, would it change your sense of pride or support for the team?
@9KPWTKZ1yr1Y
Not entirely, it is dependent on their reason for relocation of their representation. If they chose to do so, then I would harbor no ill will towards them, nor would I feel a need to support them further and I would hope that they continue to be great. If they were forced to do so, because of whatever exterior forces pushed them, then it would make me wish to support them even further.
@9KPW4G71yr1Y
I think there should be no separatism in sports, because is lowers the opportunities for individuals
@9KPW3JX1yr1Y
No it would not change my support since I cannot control it
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How has your personal history and ancestry shaped your views on the concept of having a separate state or nation?
@9JFCM791yr1Y
It has not. The U.S.A needs to correct our various problems prior to getting involved in outer issues, unless it directly affects the wellbeing of our country.
@9JKPZVY1yr1Y
We need to stop fighting in wars that do not matter. After Osama Bin Laden was killed, we stayed in the Middle East for years, losing countless American lives for no reason.
Although the US does need to deal with our own issues, but we have to consider that issues in other countries will eventually make it to is soil.
@9JFCK3L1yr1Y
i feel like it is a good thing so everything is not as crowded
@9JFCX4H1yr1Y
As a Christian, I do belive that we need separation of power and state.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Imagine if your local community had complete control over environmental regulations; what changes would you prioritize?
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What moral or ethical considerations come to mind when you think of one group separating from another?
@9HZMSTF1yr1Y
I feel separatism is not necessary and take us back in time. Everyone should be able to co-exist and work together regardless of differences. Separatism could create increased resentment and hatred amongst groups.
@9HZLWKS 1yr1Y
There is no reason for separation we are all human beings and should be treated like so.
@9HZLTR4 1yr1Y
Separatism should rely on a basis separate from what you are given at birth not including sexual orientation.
Whether they are doing it to oppress someone else, or whether the separation can be peaceful.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Reflect on a time when you felt misunderstood or overlooked by your national government; would independence alleviate these feelings?
@9HZRRJJLibertarian1yr1Y
During the 2016 elections, my parents and I were watching the Trump campaign when we heard him refer to Mexican immigrants as animals. I come from a family of Mexican immigrants. Was I, Montserrat, an animal? Was my immigrant father, whose dream was to come to America, an animal?
Growing up I've always seen my family as a typical Mexican-American family, proud of where they come from but grateful for the land of opportunity. I remember that money was always tight, so my dad took on weekends working extra hours. This caused me to rarely see him. However, no matter how stressed my parents… Read more
I felt overlooked by the national government when the government decided to go forward with abortion laws almost essentially banning it which made me feel that not many outside opinions or the populations opinion were considered for the most part and only cared for the few with power.
@9HZMWP2 1yr1Y
As an Asian woman, I feel that the government is not doing enough to keep me safe against those who feel asian hate.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What do you consider a legitimate reason for a community to want to govern itself independently?
If a community wants to govern itself independently, then the truth of the matter would be that they want to create their laws in that individual community and share ideas for what they want that community to look like.
@9HT6CJ4Republican1yr1Y
if they have a bad governor or their community is falling apart
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
In your opinion, do the benefits of separatism outweigh the potential for increased division and turmoil?
@9H7YJQ72yrs2Y
there are few benefits of separatism, and I think the US progresses better as a complete nation
Yes because you are segregating the groups instead of having them together.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
If your local community's primary language became the official language of a newly independent state, how would that make you feel?
English should be the official language in the United States, but people should be able to use whatever language they would like with friends and family.
@9KNGS8D1yr1Y
I believe a national language creates a large divide in those that don't speak it.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Can you think of an instance when a local decision made by distant politicians didn't seem to fit your community's needs?
@9KJ442XRepublican1yr1Y
The number of banks that have been allowed in our local area
@9KJ2BVQ1yr1Y
I dunno but I hate how they raised the prices for those awesome bowls at kfc
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
From your perspective, what would be the greatest challenge and the most significant benefit of a successful separatist movement?
@9LDLGYP1yr1Y
Greatest Challenge is the legality, and unity of a separationist movement within the US. I do not see much benefit in separatism. I think it would decrease national unity, legitimacy of federal government, security in North America, and more.
@9LDLXT41yr1Y
This is a racist ideology that will further increase racial divides
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Should the cultural significance of a region play a role in its political autonomy; why or why not?
@9KLS5FK 1yr1Y
I think a more federal centric government would be best rather than state centric.
Why? I have lived in Tennessee and Texas and I noticed a LOWER quality of education for Tennesseean kids. These both states are Republicans and yet the standard of education is super varied.
This made me realized to push for more federal ways rather than let states do whatever they want.
I understand some states like Texas want to separate.
I honestly think it's not a good idea for Texas to do this.
@9KLR5NH 1yr1Y
No, I just don't really care about this sort of stuff.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How do you think the inclusivity of minority voices could be affected in a region seeking to form its own government?
@9KJ2GF51yr1Y
its not true people just like to cry about anything that hurts there feelings
@9KJ29GF1yr1Y
If you dont give everyone a voice, are you really trying to build a stable government? You truly have to advocate to everyone in your nation that is hoping for you to provide them what they need.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How often do you encounter cultural or linguistic barriers that make you consider the benefits of governing your own community?
@9JFBXVJ1yr1Y
People shouldn't be blamed for being raised in another country or continent, and then come here and not be able to understand anything, because they might not have come here on their own choice. So, none at all.
@9JFBWKG1yr1Y
None, I believe what makes all cultures unique is the fact that we can come together and combine or alter cultures in a beautiful manner.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would you describe the feeling of pride or concern when hearing discussions about your region wanting to form its own state?
@9HXZN731yr1Y
I don't know enough information on it to say much. However I think we are doing good without separation of the state
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Is there a historical example of separatism you find inspirational or problematic?
@9HPQG592yrs2Y
Segregation of blacks, discriminations against Jews, Irish, and Hispanics, and Indian reservations
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What local issue do you feel would benefit most from having a government solely dedicated to your region?
@9LFLWYGRepublican1yr1Y
I feel the biggest issue would be the enforcement of laws I feel like the government wouldn't be that powerful.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Do you think cultural differences justify the creation of a new nation?
@9H3QNFX2yrs2Y
Separatism is a multi-faceted topic, with cultural differences being merely one of the several reasons a state or region may wish to separate away from the Union.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
If separation meant you could design your educational curriculum, what subjects or values would you emphasize?
@9JHP74F1yr1Y
real life situation and facts. rather than learning about what happened in 500 BC or how to find slope things will be a little more focused on reality like credit, how to budget, etc.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How do you expect the arts and local traditions to flourish differently under a government that represents a specific cultural identity?
@9LJ8FM71yr1Y
It will provide a more diverse setting that everyone can flourish under.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Do you think your personal rights would be better protected by a smaller, local government than a larger one?
@9LDV8ZM1yr1Y
Fundamental rights are best protected at the federal level and rights regarding landownership are best at the local level.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Can you share a moment when you felt a significant policy decision did not reflect the collective will of your region?
@9KJ2JG51yr1Y
I don't agree with separatism i believe that are races are equal.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would the everyday culture of your neighborhood or city be preserved or evolved in an independent state?
@9JMLLVNLibertarian1yr1Y
Our cities should be kept safe and friendly to people living there.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
If you were to draw the borders of a new country, what criteria would you use to determine its boundaries?
@9JKL9YPIndependent1yr1Y
No borders, free range. wouldn’t that be fun though? think abt it-
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would the dynamics of your family and friendships change if you were suddenly living in a newly independent state?
@9JDZMG31yr1Y
It would change drastically as there would be the obstacle of distance between my family friends and me.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Have you experienced or observed any forms of exclusion or discrimination that could fuel separatist sentiments?
@9J7LK841yr1Y
i have witnessed racism and being seperated and its disgusting
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
If an independent state meant reviving a nearly lost language or tradition, how would that affect your support?
@9KZZNHXRepublican1yr1Y
If that is what that group wants to do then they should be able to.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
To what extent should the protection of unique cultures and languages justify the formation of new nations?
@9JFDSWZ1yr1Y
We, the US should protect minorities because their cultures are unique and if we don't protect them, they will be abolished by anti-minorities.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What role do you see for immigrant communities in the dialogue around a region seeking independence?
@9KTKZS31yr1Y
In the geographic sense I support it. Far Eastern Russia has little in common with the Moscow bloc of Russia. French colonial territories have nothing in common with heartland France. I don’t believe immigrants have any real bearing in either direction for or against separatism.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would an independent state's educational system reflect your community's values and history?
@9L7FW5V1yr1Y
Education would come more from the perspective of the community
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Imagine redesigning your national flag to represent your community; what unique symbol or color would it include?
@9KPHH7N1yr1Y
Green, it would stand for more peace, community, new beginnings.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
In what ways do you think a successful separatist movement could impact global relations?
@9KSHCBSIndependent1yr1Y
Tension between races, ethnicities, and many other identities are likely to worsen if they are separated successfully from everyone else all because of who they identify as.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How might individual freedoms change if a separatist movement in your area were successful?
@9J7D6XZ1yr1Y
they would probably stay more of the same, but people would take more advantage of their movement
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How much responsibility should a new state bear for those who do not support its independence?
@9KTKJ5Y1yr1Y
I think the new state should or shouldn't feel responsible based on the type of situation they're in.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.
